Business News

The bad loans that crippled Crane Bank

Before its untimely sale to rival DFCU Bank, Crane Bank had lent clients net loans worth Sh700 billion as of October 20, 2016, according to a compiled financial report of the bank, showing that it was a key player in the country’s economy even though it was sold.
According to the leaked details of the customers contained in stolen book from former Crane Bank bosses, the asset base of Shs1.2 trillion at the time had bailed out 429 clients including individuals and companies even as its liabilities stood at Shs1.3 trillion against total equity and reserves of Shs130.9 billion. Customer deposits at the time amounted to a total of Shs977.2 billion

Data available shows big names, some politicians and businessmen who were servicing loans with the bank. Key among them include: New Vision’s Robert Kabushenga (Shs176.9m), Dr Ham Mukasa Mulira (Shs175m) and Henry Muganwa Kajura (Shs200m). Red Pepper’s Arinaitwe D. Rugyendo had a loan of Shs503.9m.
Other borrowers at the time included key figures like Patrick Bitature, former minister John Nasasira and businessman Robert Kabonero among others. Companies like Shumuk Investments, Harris International, Fountain Publishers and University Bookshop Makerere among others who took loans in hundreds of millions.
During the sale of Crane Bank then by the Bank of Uganda, shareholders argued that much as the liabilities were unfavorably, they were recovering debts from borrowers, something the central bank didn’t listen to. That was worsened as BOU handed over land titles of Crane Bank’s properties to DFCU.

Crane Bank Crane was the fourth largest bank by the time it was taken over by the central bank with branches in all regions of the country, employing thousands in direct and direct jobs. At one point it was one of the top taxpayers in the country.
More drama however ensued as DFCU Bank in mid-August announced net profits of Shs114 billion for the first half of 2017 year up from Shs23 billion in the same period last year.
DFCU attributed the profit majorly to the acquision of Crane Bank. The company’s balance sheet jumped t Shs3.05trn as of June 2017 from Shs1.8 trillon in December 2016. Its customer had numbers grow by 50 per cent in the period under review and its branch network grew from 43 to 67 with 100ATMs. But this was because it had acquired Crane Bank.
As DFCU celebrated its profit which was over 70 percent, sections of watchers in the public was wondering how a loss-making Crane Bank, as alleged by BOU, would turn around to boost profits of its rival within the shortest time.

Some have argued that the sale of Crane by BOU was for reasons best known to Governor Emmanuel Tumusiime Mutebile and sacked director of Supervision Christine Bagyenda. Mutebile at one hinted Bagyenda whose job was to scrutinize performance banks had failed to track Crane Bank, something that displeased Bagyenda. That shows the two top officials were not on the same page as Mutebile announced the sale of Crane Bank.


Court case
With Bagyenda now sacked, it is not clear whether she will be on the side of BOU in the case it accused Sudhir Ruparelia, the former Crane Bank proprietor, of taking out billions of shillings from the financial institution, causing its collapse. Sudhir denies wrong doing, arguing partly that at the takeover his bank, most of the money had been given out as loans as highlighted in the report. Sudhir blames BoU for flouting key terms of a Confidential Settlement and Release Agreement (CSRA) he signed with the central bank.
During that accounting period, Crane bank had balance with the bank of Uganda of Shs78.7b. But it also had balance and placements with other banks of above Shs10b.
Ownership

With a paid up capital of Shs210 billion, the bank was mostly owned by members of Sudhir Ruparelia family (6). Other shareholders were; White Sapphire Limited and Tom Mugenga, who had the least shares of Shs70, 014.
DFCU is partly owned by CDC, Rabo Development from the Netherlands and NorFinance from Norway who are shareholders in Arise B.V together with Norfund, a Norwegian government owned Private Equity firm and FMO, the Dutch Development Bank.

Tycoons, Ministers’ Fat Bank Loans Exposed

Crane Bank’s loans Top borrowers as of October 2016

  • The road construction company, Spencon had an outstanding loan balance of Shs 22bn.
  • Simba Telecom owned by Patrick Bitature had an outstanding amount of Shs 12bn.
  • Imperial Botanical Beach Hotel had also borrowed $4.3m (Shs 15bn) from Crane Bank.
  • Under Grapes Limited, businesswoman Amina Moghe Hersi had an unpaid balance of Shs 11bn which she acquired to expand her businesses in Kampala and Northern Uganda.
  • A Somali entrepreneur, Amina hails from the Garhajis sub-clan of the Isaaq. She owns several multimillion-dollar projects in Kampala including Oasis Shopping Mall in Kampala’s central business district and the Laburnam Courts Apartments, on Nakasero Hill
  • Goodra Behakanira Tumusiime Bwebajja, the owner of Bwebajja Hotel Complex along Entebbe Road had an outstanding loan balance of Shs 6.9bn. She recently sold Avemar Shopping Mall in Kampala to tycoon Lule Ntake at USD 8million.
  • Steel and Tube Industries had also acquired a loan of Shs 6bn.
  • Robert Mwesigwa Rukaari of international consultancy firm Amproc, had, as of October 2016, an outstanding balance of Shs 2.2bn.
  • Internal Security Organisation (ISO)  Shs 1.7bn.
  • Businessman Mukesh Shukla of Shumuk Group of Companies Shs 2bn.
  • Robert Kabonero, owner of Pyramids Casino, Kampala Casino and a city car bond had an outstanding facility of Shs 2bn.
  • Fountain Publishers, a publishing company in Uganda and Rwanda owned by James Tumusiime Shs 1.4bn.
  • Foreign Affairs Minister Sam Kutesa Shs 1bn.
  • BlueWave Beverages, producers of Bluewave mineral water Shs 833m.
  • Former ISO Director General Ronnie Balya Rwakihumuro Shs 562m.
  • Esther Ampumuza of Serene Suites Mutundwe who was struggling with a loan of Shs 600m.
  • Former ICT Minister John Nasasira had an outstanding balance of Shs 400m.
  • Kuku Foods, which supplies chicken to Kentucky Fried Chicken, an American fast food restaurant chain Shs 500m.
  • Prominent journalist Andrew Mwenda Shs 250m.
  • Still in the media fraternity, Vision Group Chief Executive Officer, Robert Kabushenga Shs 176m.
  • Former ICT Minister Ham Mulira Shs 175m while
  • Chris Katuramu, the brother of former Tooro Kingdom Premier Sanyu Katuramu Shs 197m.
  • The former First Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Public Service Henry Kajura Muganwa Shs 200m.

Read also: Report on Crane bank leaks

Related posts

Police disciplinary court demotes ASP Kirumira

BABRAH GUMOSHABE

King Saha impregnates UPDF General’s daughter

Joseph Agaba

Area Councilor, Businessman clash as locals decry over bad roads

Our Reporter